US Supreme Court rejects anti-LGBTQ+ group’s case on right to misgender trans people

The anti-LGBTQ+ group claims that their political views are being censored by Colorado lawmakers.

Photograph of the U.S Supreme Court building. This article is about Gay Against Groomer’s failed effort to appeal a ruling that insists on referring to individuals with their correct name and pronouns during legislative hearings.
Image: Jimmy Hu via Unsplash

On Monday, November 16, the US Supreme Court rejected an appeal from the Gays Against Groomers group, which opposed Colorado lawmakers’ refusal to allow witnesses to misgender and deadname transgender people during legislative hearings.

Gays Against Groomers promote themselves as an LGBTQ+ organisation devoted to protecting children. However, they have been identified by Southern Poverty Law Centre as an anti-LGBTQ+ hate group who echo far-right sentiments including conspiracy theories which liken gender-affirming healthcare to child abuse.

The Supreme Court justices refused to hear the lawsuit without comment, thus ending the case without settling whether restrictions on misgendering are in opposition to the First Amendment.

Controversy surrounding this issue first arose in 2024 when Colorado lawmakers sought to enact Tiara’s Law, which makes it easier for individuals convicted of a felony to legally change their name. Rich Guggenheim of Gays Against Groomers and Christina Goeke of the Rocky Mountain Women’s Network stood in opposition to the measure and alleged that their testimony was interrupted after they refused to use the correct name and pronouns when addressing Tiara Latrice Kelley, the transgender woman whom the bill was named after. 

Goeke also claimed that portions of her testimony were removed from the legislative record. Consequently, the anti-LGBTQ+ activists sued on the grounds that lawmakers were discriminating against their political beliefs. The federal district court dismissed the lawsuit in November 2024. 

In the recent case, the Institute of Free Speech (representing Gays Against Groomers) argued that the court ruling was in violation of the First Amendment. They were critical of the decision, with senior attorney Del Kolde stating, “We’re disappointed that the Court declined to take up this case”.

Gays Against Groomers was founded by Jaimee Michell in 2022. Michell has been outspoken in spreading anti-LGBTQ+ rhetoric and after the mass shooting at Club Q, she spoke to Tucker Carlson on Fox News and proclaimed that shootings of this nature would continue so long as the “evil agenda” of gender-affirming healthcare was available. 

Tiara Latrice Kelley worked at Club Q and lost two friends to the mass shooting.

© 2026 GCN (Gay Community News). All rights reserved.

Support GCN

GCN is a free, vital resource for Ireland’s LGBTQ+ community since 1988.

GCN is a trading name of National LGBT Federation CLG, a registered charity - Charity Number: 20034580.

GCN relies on the generous support of the community and allies to sustain the crucial work that we do. Producing GCN is costly, and, in an industry which has been hugely impacted by rising costs, we need your support to help sustain and grow this vital resource.

Supporting GCN for as little as €1.99 per month will help us continue our work as Ireland’s free, independent LGBTQ+ media.