Campaigners Cautiously Welcome Abortion Referendum's "Repeal And Replace" Proposal

Voters will be asked to vote on Oireachtas legislation that would replace the Eighth Amendment of the Constitution.

Eighth Amendment protest

It has been almost 35 years since the Irish public voted to enter the Eighth Amendment into the Constitution giving the mother and the unborn an equal right to life.

Since then, there have been four other abortion referendums, which gave women the right to travel and the right to information.

During a lengthy cabinet meeting last night, ministers came to a unanimous decision to propose a “repeal and replace” referendum on abortion.

Taoiseach Leo Varadkar explained during a press conference that in accordance with the Oireachtas Committee on the Eighth Amendment, legislation will be introduced to allow for abortion on request up to 12 weeks.

As part of the speech, Varadkar said: “(the referendum is) a decision about whether we want to continue to stigmatise & criminalise our sisters, our co-workers, our friends. Or whether we are prepared…. to show empathy and compassion”.

In terms of legislation, it will be a complex process. The Government stated its intention to insert a new ‘enabling clause’ to the Constitution. The details of this have yet to be released.

In relation to this, the Coalition to Repeal the Eighth Amendment released a statement:

“It is the Government’s intention to propose new wording for insertion in the Constitution, which would explicitly empower the Oireachtas to legislate for the provision of abortion in Ireland. It is our view that given the historically complicated nature of the debate on the issue in Ireland, the Government has an obligation to explain the reasons for inserting a new ‘enabling clause’ in the Constitution in the clearest possible terms.”

The Abortion Rights Campaign also released a statement regarding the Constitutional element:

“We would still prefer if abortion care was not singled out in our Constitution, but we are willing to support this provision, if worded properly, and heed the legal advice given by the Attorney General.


Public Reaction

Campaigners have cautiously welcomed the announcement and have stated that they will be keeping a close watch on proceedings over the following months.

The Abortion Rights Campaign (ARC) today welcomed the Government’s “repeal and enact” proposal.

Spokesperson Linda Kavanagh said:

Modern, accessible and compassionate abortion care must be a guaranteed outcome of the referendum passing – that is non-negotiable.

“While ARC has always campaigned for repeal simpliciter as advised by the Joint Oireachtas Committee, it appears that the enabling provision proposed by the Government will remove the constitutional barrier to abortion care and allow for more progressive and compassionate healthcare to be provided for all those who can get pregnant.

“However we will be watching the Government very closely and encouraging our members and supporters to do the same in the weeks ahead with regards to the wording of a referendum bill and the proposed legislation. Generations of people have fought too long and too hard for change in our abortion laws, and we will not accept any fudges or half-measures. Modern, accessible and compassionate abortion care must be a guaranteed outcome of the referendum passing – that is non-negotiable.

“We are looking forward to an energetic, compassionate, and respectful referendum campaign. We are repealing the 8th Amendment because we want an Ireland where everyone has access to compassionate, timely, local healthcare.”

Orla O’Connor, Director of the National Women’s Council of Ireland (NWCI), said

“It is an acknowledgement that the Constitution is no place for meeting the complexities of women’s needs in pregnancy and that we must allow doctors to apply best medical practice and care for all of their patients in this country without fear of prosecution.”

There were also many reactions across Twitter from organisations and campaigners about the announcement:


© 2018 GCN (Gay Community News). All rights reserved.

0 comments. Please sign in to comment.